I like to build furniture. Let’s say that I am also a forest warden, and I love to grow trees. I love the trees for their beauty in their own right and I love them because I can harvest them and make nice furniture. If I want to make good furniture, I know I need good, straight-grained, blemish-free wood. But if I love trees to be trees, I know I need them to grow as they must, blemishes and all. So, I have a choice: I can plant all my trees in specially constructed boxes and growth chambers that constricts their growth and yields me 99.99% perfect wood for my furniture, but a REALLY boring, ugly, monotonous forest (and needless to say, the trees in this forest have no fun whatsoever and would hate being there). OR, I can let the trees grow as is their nature, some beautiful and vibrant, some not, some good for furniture and some not. But, I know that the forest will be what a forest must be. Some trees having fun, some not, forests being what forests are, if not constrained by me. So, I decide to let forests be forests AND harvest trees to make my furniture (it’s my forest after all). Some blemishes I can incorporate into my furniture design and some I can’t. The blemishes I can’t use, I have to cut away and feed the cut-offs to my stove. In addition, there will be trees that are in no way suited for furniture at all and will simply need to be left to decompose where they stand.
From a utilitarian perspective the former alternative of machined tree-growth seems optimal, though pity the trees. From a libertarian perspective, the free-forest alternative seems optimal, though pity the trees who don’t make it into furniture. The atheist perspective seems to be there can be no furniture-maker who desires beautiful furniture AND free trees, since, after all, SOME trees must either burn or decompose. So, as the atheist would have it, since trees actually do exist (presumably without constraint) they are ALL free trees hurtling through space, slowly decomposing for no purpose at all.
I’ve made up my mind: I am going to be a rocking chair, and a Maloof rocker at that!