I have mentioned before that shaking one’s fist at God is absurd. Let me unpack that a little better: Seems to me that the situation is fairly simple. Either God exists or He doesn’t. We can quibble about His nature, though it seems to me that if God exists then the description of him in Scripture is pretty much what you’d expect. But, at a minimum, He would be Omniscient, Omnipresent, Omnipotent and all that.
So, to the fist shaking, either:
1) God does not exist. Seems to me that shaking your fist at something that does not exist is not particularly cogent. In fact, it is likely delusional.
2) God does exist. Well, then, what ARE we thinking? Clearly, we have in this case no idea who we are dealing with. Us humans, shaking our fists at GOD??
One of my favorite movie scenes is from Batman, The Dark Knight. An accountant for the Wayne Corp thinks he has uncovered the truth of Batman’s identity through a money flow to the secret lab, and he goes to Batman’s corporate right-hand man played by Morgan Freeman, demanding $ millions a month for life. Freeman leans back in his chair, tenting his fingers together and says: “Let me get this straight: You think you’ve discovered that your boss is a masked vigilante who beats bad guys to a pulp for fun. And this man you are going to blackmail??” Needless to say, nothing comes of the extortion attempt. But it is instructive: Know who you are dealing with and act accordingly. If we are truly convinced God does not exist, and the point of life is to grab as much utility for ourselves as possible, then we don’t care who we step on to get what we want. But who really does that? Most if not all people will actually not live this way but constrain themselves as if God does exist. There is a lot of research suggesting that people do not make decisions based on pure self-interest, but rather based on group identity. Now, why would they do THAT? Theories abound about the evolutionary advantage of group-belonging (and its pretty intuitive), but we still have plenty of examples to the contrary. Most, if not all, post-modern theorizing is based on the principle of power: Who has it, who can get it, how to redistribute it…And, still, we by and large do not live this way.
On the other hand, if we are convinced God DOES exist then it would seem quite imperative to
1) find out who He is and what He would want of us, then
2) DO THAT.