A cousin of mine had an interesting comment as we commiserated about my mom’s passing: “…the baton (of being head of the family) is passed on to the next generation” (that would be my brother and I, I guess). This struck me as oddly anachronistic in today’s culture. We live in a “diverse” and, one could argue, headless society. No-one is the head of anyone, save oneself of oneself, whatever that might mean. In days of yore, one could look to the family “head” as a source of wisdom, experience, steadiness, groundedness. (You can see my prior comments on the “Patriarchy” here). No longer. Everyone is free to do what is right in their own eyes, express their true selves as they see fit, totally liberated.
This is good?
Seems more like a recipe for chaos, if you ask me. If we are all free-floating monads buffered from one another and touch each other only accidentally. Such touching becomes abusive and our egos become über-fragile (See Taylor 2007, Trueman 2020, Mounk 2023). This is because our intrinsic nature as human beings is communal. We are social, communal creatures. Homo Sapiens tend to cluster together, and whenever they do, they build structures; cultural and material structures. You can’t have life together without them, and structure entails an ordering, and ordering entails hierarchy. Seems it has been thus since the dawn of time.
From a biblical perspective, we are destined to become living stones in the body of Christ. We are shaped to fit into this structure by how we live our communal life here and now. So, to destroy the communal aspect of our lives must ultimately chip away at our very selves. No wonder anxiety, depression, suicide are on the rise if nobody can feel the connection, safety and succor of life together. The key principle in communal life is “my life for yours”. Preoccupation with self, even in the form of self denial, isolates us from life together and enslaves us to life for self. Life together has many members, different functions, talents, gifts, weaknesses. The organic whole is greater than the sum of its parts as long as the parts are in harmony with one another. The organic whole evolves and morphs over time as these parts learn to harmonize. Key to such a symphony is knowing the underlying theme and the method of participation. Yes, yes, there are the likes of John Cage, sticking forks amongst the piano strings. But even this plays a role when the full score is looked at from a divine perspective. But it starts with each individual taking on the mind of Christ, who, though he was in the form of God, did not count being God a thing He had to hoard to himself but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, in the likeness of men. And being found in human form, he humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross. (Phil 2:6-8, my translation, mostly). His life for ours, my life for yours, life together, in covenantal obedience to God and submission to each other, becoming living stones in the body of Christ.
I think this excerpt from BB Warfield (1851-1921) fleshes it out brilliantly (“Imitating the incarnation”, in The Person and Work of Christ, Appendix D. P&R publishing 2023, courtesy Pastor Matt):
“Our self-abnegation is thus not for our own sake, but for the sake of others. And thus it is not to mere self-denial that Christ calls us, but specifically to self-sacrifice: not to unselfing ourselves, but to unselfishing ourselves. Self-denial for its own sake is in its very nature ascetic, monkish. It concentrates our whole attention on self—self-knowledge, self-control—and can therefore eventuate in nothing other than the very apotheosis of selfishness. At best it succeeds only in subjecting the outer self to the inner self, or the lower self to the higher self; and only the more surely falls into the slough of self-seeking, that it partially conceals the selfishness of its goal by refining its ideal of self and excluding its grosser and more outward elements. Self-denial, then, drives to the cloister; narrows and contracts the soul; murders within us all innocent desires, dries up all the springs of sympathy, and nurses and coddles our self-importance until we grow so great in our own esteem as to be careless of the trials and sufferings, the joys and aspirations, the strivings and failures and successes of our fellow-men. Self-denial, thus understood, will make us cold, hard, unsympathetic,—proud, arrogant, self-esteeming,—fanatical, overbearing, cruel. It may make monks and Stoics,—it cannot make Christians.
It is not to this that Christ’s example calls us. He did not cultivate self, even His divine self: He took no account of self. He was not led by His divine impulse out of the world, driven back into the recesses of His own soul to brood morbidly over His own needs, until to gain His own seemed worth all sacrifice to Him. He was led by His love for others into the world, to forget Himself in the needs of others, to sacrifice self once for all upon the altar of sympathy. Self-sacrifice brought Christ into the world. And self-sacrifice will lead us, His followers, not away from but into the midst of men. Wherever men suffer, there will we be to comfort. Wherever men strive, there will we be to help. Wherever men fail, there will be we to uplift. Wherever men succeed, there will we be to rejoice. Self-sacrifice means not indifference to our times and our fellows: it means absorption in them. It means forgetfulness of self in others. It means entering into every man’s hopes and fears, longings and despairs: it means manysidedness of spirit, multiform activity, multiplicity of sympathies. It means richness of development. It means not that we should live one life, but a thousand lives,—binding ourselves to a thousand souls by the filaments of so loving a sympathy that their lives become ours. It means that all the experiences of men shall smite our souls and shall beat and batter these stubborn hearts of ours into fitness for their heavenly home. It is, after all, then, the path to the highest possible development, by which alone we can be made truly men. Not that we shall undertake it with this end in view. This were to dry up its springs at their source. We cannot be self-consciously self-forgetful, selfishly unselfish. Only, when we humbly walk this path, seeking truly in it not our own things but those of others, we shall find the promise true, that he who loses his life shall find it. Only, when, like Christ, and in loving obedience to His call and example, we take no account of ourselves, but freely give ourselves to others, we shall find, each in his measure, the saying true of himself also: “Wherefore also God hath highly exalted him.” The path of self-sacrifice is the path to glory.”