The concept of hell and eternal torment is repugnant to many of us, to the point where many reject God all together if God entails/requires such a thing. However, I think there are many reasons why hell is not only possible, but necessary and also an expression of God’s goodness and benevolence. Paradoxes in the Christian faith do abound! But, there are a few Scriptural givens and a pretty solid logic that must be mapped out:
1) God exists and in Him there can be no darkness or evil. Any evil, if it exists, must therefore be separated from God “as far as the east is from the west”.
2) Spiritual creatures (us, and angels, I suppose) are created eternal beings for whom non-existence/annihilation is not possible.
3) No one goes to hell (or heaven) without hearing the Gospel (i.e.: the good news that there is a way out!)
4) We choose to reject God. Though God may know what we do before we do it, we still do whatever of our own accord.
5) Evil actually does exist. I doubt anyone would really disagree with that. Aristotle’s idea that “evil” is simply confusion is belied by history.
6) It follows from the above that if God, as pure goodness exists and evil exists and evil must be separated from God as far as “east is from west”, then it follows that there must be hell. This seems an inevitable conclusion.
We might try to argue that even if evil does exist, but Hell is so repugnant that it could not exist, therefore God cannot exist. So, the existence of evil excludes the possibility of a (benevolent) god. I think there are many blind alleys in this way of thinking:
1) The fact that we find something repugnant does not exclude its existence.
2) If there is no (benevolent) god, then how can there be “evil”, as opposed to a mere tail on a distribution of behavior?
3) As I have argued elsewhere, suffering the consequences of our own decisions is not unjust.
4) If there is no hell, then there can be no justice. Since we agree that evil exists, simply absolving evil would be unjust. Justice/fairness is central to how we view ourselves as moral beings. Who would not want to see Hitler etc. in hell?
5) Further to point #4, we also are deficient in our appreciation of the true nature of sin. By dismissing hell, we are tacitly or overtly minimizing sin. Sin really isn’t all that bad, certainly not deserving of hell. Yet Jesus is very clear that sin really is that bad because it separates us from God. Further, minimizing sin therefore minimizes God, for there can be NO darkness in Him AT ALL
6) Our picture of hell is also wrong. We wrongly assume that hell is a place where unrepentant sinners are tormented by someone/something else as some kind of retribution, or worse: Some form of amusement for heavenly beings.
I don’t think this is so. Consider a real-life situation I think we’ve all experienced: Doing something incredibly stupid. I can for my part think of many, some of which were REALLY awful. As these come to my mind I pull my hair, grit my teeth and scream to myself: “How COULD you do/say/think something like that?? GOOD GRIEF!!”. Now, imagine being separated from God, FOREVER, knowing you chose this yourself because you were just being so full of yourself. Imagine the teeth grinding, hair pulling, self-recrimination! Such a person will not need any little red guy with a pointed tail and a pitchfork to torment them. They will do so very well on their own, thank you very much.
Hugh Ross (1999) gives another interesting answer to the question “how is hell compatible with a loving god?”: Torment in hell is individualized for the very purpose of restraint! Even in hell the people there are not as evil as they could be. The torment they experience restrains them from the full exercise of their evil. Heaven will be as glorious as it possibly could get. Hell will never be as awful as it could be. By the Grace of God.
We also have a tendency to wonder why bad things happen to good people. The answer here is obvious: There are no good people. Hell was always postlapsarian humanity’s destiny. Only by God’s Grace in sacrificing His Son is an avenue opened for fallen man to escape the judgement he was already in. God’s love is expressed, in part, by His gift of freedom, freedom to choose for ourselves as independent free agents. What we can’t choose is to avoid the consequences of our own choices. There are certainly things I would desperately wish my children would choose and things I wish they would avoid. Yet, in my love for them I do not constrain them. I might (and have) tried to inform them, guide them and protect them. Though, ultimately, if I truly love and respect them, I must let them make their own decisions. For better or for worse. Thus, also for God. If some of us are determined to reject Him, then so be it.
So, the existence of hell is not only not incompatible with the existence of a benevolent God, it is an inevitable consequence of freedom, love, man and God. Ultimately, what God chooses to do with this in the future is surely up to Him. Eternity is a very long time.