While enjoying some time off deep in the fjordlands of Norway, I had the opportunity to read through a few interesting books:
“The Abolition of Man” by CS Lewis (1943),
“On Freedom” By Timothy Snyder (2024),
“Why Nations Fail” by Daren Asimoglu (2012)
“Thinking fast and slow” by Daniel Kahneman (2013).
It’s so wonderful to have a good chunk of time to read and contemplate without interruption, particularly when your environment is tranquil. Many threads come together and some shoot out into outer space. It’s fun! I wanted to write down some impressions and will elaborate further is subsequent posts. I want to start with Snyder’s book. I think, in general, it is a very hopeful and humane book, as one would expect of a brilliant and gracious man as Tim Snyder. I found a lot of “process thinking”: (as opposed to “goal-oriented thinking”), much of it loosely defined though quintessentially hopeful in a good outcome, or at least in the possibility of a good outcome as long as we all respect and accommodate each other. That said, I can’t help but liken the concept he seems to be describing to a lava lamp: Always in motion, new shapes and sizes, all fascinating and engrossing though without a clear starting point and not really going anywhere but simply morphing from one constellation to the next with no telos. I will say that the undercurrent of hopefulness and faith in human nature from Snyder is refreshing, coming from a historian, particularly an expert in eastern European history which is anything but rosy.
I find myself in such sympathy with Snyder I found myself exclaiming:
Freedom-TO rather than just freedom-from. Yes.
Whole person, the “lieb”, not just matter- “körper”. Yes!
Root life in values. YES!
Responsible government to enforce, uphold values. YES!!
Allow innovation and unpredictability. YESSS!!!
But…
Houston, we have a problem.
In order to address the book in at least a modicum of detail and honor, I’ll have to do it in a series of posts, tackling one issue at a time, which will come over the next several weeks. That said, what I found most disappointing, if that is really the word for it, was that there is very little new here. Snyder couches his ethical and societal issues in very relevant and current forms with a great deal of personal experience and insightful detail, but the book is still an exposition of utopian yearnings that have all been expressed before by a number of people over a lot of years. One cannot help but think that if this is all so wonderful and so doable, how come we haven’t done it yet? Surely a historian of Snyder’s caliber would see the barriers that have been erected over the years (and indeed he does point out some of them), but there are very few actionable solutions to get us there apart from yearning for a niceness towards one another since we occupy the same space. There are allusions to some erst-while examples of what Snyder describes (Scandinavia and Canada in particular), but (spoiler alert:) they are not, at least not the shining examples Snyder envisions. So, a bit of real-politik would quickly be a wet blanket on the whole enterprise. This is not to say we should not aspire or try to champion a better society. We should. We should also, however, avoid tilting at windmills and make sure that we bite off pieces we can actually chew and get through the whole meal.
So there will be 7 posts to follow:
On Freedom-TO
On the “lieb”
On values
On unpredicatbility
On Community/government
On Health care
Some final thoughts
Stay tiuned…