I’m back! Well, I hope. I’d say I’ve had a bit of writer’s block of late, though that would assume that I am a writer, in more than the strictest technical sense. This remains to be seen, I suppose. Be that as it may, I think I’ve also been a bit depressed, and depression turns down your creative energies in a big way. I’m dismayed at the state of our world, from individual relationships to big-picture geopolitical situations. It all seems such a mess. What strikes me the most in this polarization, that seems to be becoming more and more often violent, is that there seems to be no effort at understanding, both of “the other side” and of the wider context of things. If you disagree with me you are clearly part of “them” and “they” are evil, by definition. It’s a lot like the old Marxist-Leninist approach to things: If you do not whole-heartedly subscribe to (our) historic inevitability, then you must be insane and we’ll place you in a mental hospital (or gulag as the case may be) and medicate/indoctrinate you until you see the light, or we make you go away permanently.
While I do not subscribe to the idea that compromise is actually the goal of the democratic process, I think persuasion is, I think compromise at least entails sufficient understanding on all sides of an issue in order to reach the compromise. So in that sense it is probably better than a Mexican standoff. But, as I said, I think persuasion and reasonableness is much better because this would be superior to regression to the mean. Persuasion would actually advance our understanding and move our social development onward, instead of endlessly circling the drain.
I’ve not heard, seen or read anything that Charlie Kirk said or wrote, but it seems to me that he at least tried to promote a reasoned debate. He was clearly not universally successful, and his polemical methods and some of his stances may have been odious, at least to some. But the tragedy here is that the recourse seems to be to violence. Either emotional or physical. To the point of killing. That should make us all sad, perhaps even willing to take a more sober look at where we stand as a culture and how got here.
I can recall, back in the day when political correctness and “Wokism” started gaining steam. When cancel culture really took off and the debate went off the rails. A lot of us would argue that introducing coercive structures into a culture is a very dangerous thing, since, eventually, the “other” side would gain ascendancy and then leverage those very structures against the folks who put them there to begin with. I think we are at that point now. The MAGA folks are turning the tables on the “WOKES” and gleefully cheering as the shoe is now on the other foot, and how! While there may be some short-term gratification in this, the pendulum will inevitably swing the other way and so it’ll go on, forever.
Unless we realize that there is a greater good. We should not celebrate narcissism and score-settling but rather sacrificial contribution to those things that benefit us all. We need to know what is petty hubris and what is meaningful and important. We need to reclaim the sacred, whether secular priorities or religious ones is less relevant. We need to understand that level playing fields and distributed power are effective ways of evening things out for everyone. We need to know that a culture of envy is not healthy, and that ignoring fundamental needs will lead to disaster. We need to know that in order to know these things we need to listen, discuss reasonably and understand, BEFORE we jump to conclusions and label others as evil. We need to know that this must start at home, with our families, in our neighborhoods, churches and civic organizations. We need to know that basic logic is not a tool of male oppression of women (or other men) but the bedrock on which any kind of understanding is possible at all. So, we need to learn how to think clearly. This would entail ratcheting the temperature WAY down. Chill, have a beer, or a cup of tea…
We actually have a wonderful example to follow, as the apostle Paul describes in Philippians 2 (and I paraphrase): Although Christ is Lord and Creator of the universe, He did not consider this something to hoard to himself, but set it aside and in obedience to the Father took on the form of man to redeem His creation in love. What if we did something similar? What if we set aside that which we felt was our human right, for the greater good? Where would anger be? Where would violence be? Anxiety? Hate?
Might be worth thinking about and discussing.