And now, for something completely different

A) JM’s FORMULATION:

PREMISES:

P1) ∀x(C(x) → T(x, w))

All created things were made through the Word

P2) ¬∃x(C(x) ∧ ¬T(x, w))

No created thing was made apart from the Word

P3) ¬∃x(T(x, x))

Nothing is the instrument of its own creation

P4) ∀x(¬C(x) → U(x))

Everything not created is uncreated/divine

DERIVATION:

(4) C(w) → T(w, w)

Universal Instantiation on P1, x = w

(5) ¬T(w, w)

From P3 (instantiated to w)

(6) ¬C(w)

Modus Tollens on (4), (5)

(7) ¬C(w) → U(w)

Universal Instantiation on P4, x = w

(C) U(w)

Modus Ponens on (6), (7)

CONCLUSION:

The Word (w) is uncreated and divine.

B) J’s FORMULATION

DOMAIN: All things that exist.

DEFINITIONS:

w = Word/ Logos [That exists]

x = A thing that exists

C( ) = Created

U( ) = Uncreated

T(x,y) = A causal relation, x is caused by y

a → b = A logical relation, if a then b

PREDICATES:

C(x) = x is a created thing that exists

U(y) = y is an uncreated thing that exists

T(x, w) = the instrumental cause of x is w

PREMISES:

∃(x)

∃(x) = w ∧ ¬∀(x) = w → ∃(w)

∀x(C(x) → T(x, w)) ≡ ¬∃x(C(x) ∧ ¬T(x, w))

[ I think we’d have to say ∀x≠w(C(x)… since we claim that w is a thing that exists]

¬∃x(T(x, x)) ∧ ¬∃wC(w) → ¬T(w, w)

[Again, I think we’d have to say ¬∃x≠w(T(x,x)…]

CONCLUSION:

∀x(¬C(x) → U(x)) → U(w)

This seems to reduce to a tautology: the uncreated word/logos is uncreated.

I suppose that we’re assuming that U(x) ≡  divine,

though the syllogism does not require only one w among all x.

Furthermore, it does not seem to prove that w actually exists (it assumes w exists),

nor does this particular syllogism seem to prove that if there are created things there must be uncreated thing(s)

since created things can create other created things

C) D’S REFORMULATION WITH EXPLANATIONS:

DEFINITIONS:

x∈R | R≠∅ (or |R|>0)  and ∀x∃y(y=x)

Domain: all things that exist

w = Word/ Logos[That exists]

…including this makes things tricky because if w does not in fact exist,

then we are talking about something outside the domain,

so either switch to universal domain and state that there exists an x,

or let the domain restriction do the work.

x = a

variable that can be substituted with any eligible arbitrary or non-arbitrary name,

subject to the quantifier binding x in a sentence.

Cx = x

is created

Ux = x

is uncreated (and presumably ¬Cx↔Ux but not strictly

¬C_=U_ just like p if and only if ¬¬p but p ≠ ¬¬p;

the predicates are coextensive but non-identical)

T(x,y) (Or Txy)= A

causal relation, x is caused by y (this smuggles in a few counterfactual claims,

and thus a few assumptions about other possible worlds;

I think the work it wants to do is claim that x is always and only caused by y).

p → q = the material conditional; “if… then…” or “…only if…”

PREMISES:

1.    ∃x(x=w)∧∃x(x≠w)

There is just one element in R that is w, and there is an element in R that is not w.

This is what ∃(x) = w ∧ ¬∀(x) = w → ∃(w) was doing before.

2.    ¬∃x(Cx ∧ ¬Txw)  ∀x(Cx → Txw)  ↔ ¬∃x(Cx ∧ ¬Txw)

[ I think we’d have to say ∀x≠w(C(x)… since we claim that w is a thing that exists] 

It’s fine as is, it doesn’t claim that all x∈R are created. 

∀x(C(x) → Txw) just says “for any given thing, x, if x is created then w causes x.”

But it may not be created; in fact, the conditional would be trivially true even if

¬∃xCx, or alternatively, if ∀x¬Cx; nothing is created.

I am only using one side as a premise because both sides are logically equivalent,

what you want is the truth claim that “there exists no x such that x was created and x was not ‘caused’ by w.”

 3.   ¬∃xTxx

There is no x such that x is caused by x

 4.   ¬Cw

It is false that w was created; or, w is not created

 (¬∃xTxx ∧ ¬Cw) → ¬Tww

(3) and (4) [Again, I think we’d have to say ¬∃x≠w(T(x,x)…]

(no, but you wouldn’t say ¬∃wCw because, for our purposes,

w is a name rather than a variable. We would just say ¬Cw.

But ¬Tww follows from ¬∃xTxx:

¬∃xTxx⊨∀x¬Txx,∀x¬Txx ⊢¬Tww (given that w is a name in the domain))

  5.   ∀x(¬Cx → Ux) 

For any given x if x is not created then x is uncreated (this is a definition).

I’m not sure why there are two predicates doing the “was not created” work;

unless there is a philosophical or logical distinction between not being created and being uncreated,

we could just use ¬CxIt doesn’t seem to me that the conclusion is really “if for all x,

if x is not created then x is uncreated, then w is uncreated.” It certainly doesn’t need that work.

CONCLUSION:

U(w)

“the word is uncreated”. I don’t think this is what you want to say, but if it was then the only premises you’d need are 4 and 5:

ALTERNATIVE:
1.     ¬Cw                                         

Premise

2.     ∀x(¬Cx → Ux)

Premise (But follows from the definition (¬Cx ↔  Ux)

3.     ¬Cw → Uw

Instantiating the universal [x=w], Universal remains open

C. /∴Uw                                       

 1,3 Modus Ponens

But this is a fallacy, technically, because ¬Cx is definitionally equivalent to Ux,

so the conclusion, Ux, is already in the premise.

But I think this must not be the conclusion you’re looking for either.

There are a few things I think might be missing,

but one is something along the lines of  ∀x∃yTxy;

the current system leaves open the possibility of uncaused things.

But I think my big question is what the real conclusion is.

Previous
Previous

Further down the rabbit trail

Next
Next

Ecce Homo III