Further down the rabbit trail

See our last installment here. Here’s more from D.

In the universal domain

Names:

w: the word

Cx: x is created

Dx: x is divine

Txy: y is caused by x

Premises:

1. βˆƒπ’™(𝒙 = π’˜) ∧ βˆƒπ’š(π’š β‰  π’˜)

The word exists and there is something other than word.

2. βˆ€π’™(π‘ͺ𝒙 β†’ π‘»π’˜π’™)

Everything that is created is created by the word

3. Β¬βˆƒπ’™π‘»π’™π’™

Nothing is self-causing

4. βˆ€π’™(π‘ͺ𝒙 ∨ 𝑫𝒙)

Everything is either created or divine

4*. βˆ€π’™(π‘ͺ𝒙 βŠ• 𝑫𝒙)

Stronger: Everything is either created or divine, but nothing is both

Proof:

1. βˆƒπ‘₯(π‘₯ = 𝑀) ∧ βˆƒπ‘¦(𝑦 β‰  𝑀)

Premise 1

1.a βˆƒπ‘₯(π‘₯ = 𝑀)

1, simplification (Closed, 5)

1.b βˆƒπ‘¦(𝑦 β‰  𝑀)

1, simplification (Closed, 6)

2. βˆ€π‘₯(𝐢π‘₯ β†’ 𝑇𝑀π‘₯)

Premise 2

3. Β¬βˆƒπ‘₯𝑇π‘₯π‘₯

Premise 3

4. π‘Ž = 𝑀

a is a non-arbitrary name for the word (1.a, EI [x/a])

5. 𝑏 β‰  𝑀

b is a non-arbitrary name for the thing that is not the word (1.b, EI, [y/b])

6. 𝑏 β‰  π‘Ž

a and b are distinct, by 5, 6, substitution

7.a πΆπ‘Ž β†’ π‘‡π‘€π‘Ž

2, UI [x/a]

7.b 𝐢𝑏 β†’ 𝑇𝑀𝑏

2, UI [x/b]

7.c 𝐢𝑀 β†’ 𝑇𝑀𝑀

2, UI [x/w]

8. βˆ€π‘₯¬𝑇π‘₯π‘₯

3, Negated Existential

9. ¬𝑇𝑀𝑀

8, UI [x/w]

10. ¬𝐢𝑀 7.c

9, Modus Tollens

11. βˆ€π‘₯(𝐢π‘₯ ∨ 𝐷π‘₯)

Premise 4

12. 𝐢𝑀 ∨ 𝐷𝑀

11, UI [x/w]

13. 𝐷𝑀 10

12, Disjunctive Syllogism; β€œthe word is divine”

14. ∴ βˆƒπ‘₯𝐷π‘₯

13, Existential generalization; β€œsomething divine exists”

QED

My impression is the original article was only meant to show that John 1:1-3 was valid. It is valid but has some problems; because of how it is constructed, it may not be sound, it begs the question, and it leaves open the option that there exists a thing that is divine and uncreated but is not the word. There’s some baggage; there’s really no reason to include the assumption that anything besides the word exists. We never call b, our token non-the word thing, for anything in the argument. Further, we cannot conclude that there is anything that is created, without at least the exclusive disjunction (4*). This is true even though we assume that something other than the world does, in fact, exist.

Previous
Previous

A free man on a long journey

Next
Next

And now, for something completely different