See our last installment here. Hereβs more from D.
In the universal domain
Names:
w: the word
Cx: x is created
Dx: x is divine
Txy: y is caused by x
Premises:
1. βπ(π = π) β§ βπ(π β π)
The word exists and there is something other than word.
2. βπ(πͺπ β π»ππ)
Everything that is created is created by the word
3. Β¬βππ»ππ
Nothing is self-causing
4. βπ(πͺπ β¨ π«π)
Everything is either created or divine
4*. βπ(πͺπ β π«π)
Stronger: Everything is either created or divine, but nothing is both
Proof:
1. βπ₯(π₯ = π€) β§ βπ¦(π¦ β π€)
Premise 1
1.a βπ₯(π₯ = π€)
1, simplification (Closed, 5)
1.b βπ¦(π¦ β π€)
1, simplification (Closed, 6)
2. βπ₯(πΆπ₯ β ππ€π₯)
Premise 2
3. Β¬βπ₯ππ₯π₯
Premise 3
4. π = π€
a is a non-arbitrary name for the word (1.a, EI [x/a])
5. π β π€
b is a non-arbitrary name for the thing that is not the word (1.b, EI, [y/b])
6. π β π
a and b are distinct, by 5, 6, substitution
7.a πΆπ β ππ€π
2, UI [x/a]
7.b πΆπ β ππ€π
2, UI [x/b]
7.c πΆπ€ β ππ€π€
2, UI [x/w]
8. βπ₯Β¬ππ₯π₯
3, Negated Existential
9. Β¬ππ€π€
8, UI [x/w]
10. Β¬πΆπ€ 7.c
9, Modus Tollens
11. βπ₯(πΆπ₯ β¨ π·π₯)
Premise 4
12. πΆπ€ β¨ π·π€
11, UI [x/w]
13. π·π€ 10
12, Disjunctive Syllogism; βthe word is divineβ
14. β΄ βπ₯π·π₯
13, Existential generalization; βsomething divine existsβ
QED
My impression is the original article was only meant to show that John 1:1-3 was valid. It is valid but has some problems; because of how it is constructed, it may not be sound, it begs the question, and it leaves open the option that there exists a thing that is divine and uncreated but is not the word. Thereβs some baggage; thereβs really no reason to include the assumption that anything besides the word exists. We never call b, our token non-the word thing, for anything in the argument. Further, we cannot conclude that there is anything that is created, without at least the exclusive disjunction (4*). This is true even though we assume that something other than the world does, in fact, exist.