A free man on a long journey

What do David Chalmer’s book “Reality+” (2022), two movies “The Matrix” (1999) and “The Shawshank Redemption” (1994) and Paul’s letter to the Galatians have in common?

Mindsets.

We learn from John 1:1 that “In the beginning was the λόγος (logos, word), and the λόγος was with God and the λόγος was God”.  The world comes from the mind of God. I think that David Chalmer’s notion of a “simulation” or “virtual world” could be a good metaphor with which to think about this, though I am definitely not likening God to some kind of über-programmer with a really powerful computer (or a tired-looking black woman baking cookies, for that matter). What God “simulates” is what we call “reality”. God’s mind creates a world where He gives human minds freedom to create our own worlds within His world. We all create worlds, that’s what our brains do. This is one way we are made in God’s image. The worlds we create are based on narratives, or mindsets if you will, that determine how we interact with the world around us, and determine what we perceive of the “outside” world. The issue is: Will the human worlds we create harmonize with the world that God creates or will they shoot off on their own and conflict with God and His world?

Worlds have structure, regardless of who creates them. You can’t have harmony without structure. Our worlds have our own structure, what Paul alludes to with a term usually translated as “elementary principles of the world” (Gal 4:3), στοιχεῖα (stoicheia), a term relating to order/relationship of basic quantities. Paul is saying that we can order our world, our mindset, according to our own, simple order or to God’s. Clinging to our own στοιχεῖα, however, is a trap, a prison, a dividing wall of hostility (Eph 2:14) because it separates us from God. Since God’s world is obviously the ultimate world, aligning with Him would be the optimal solution. Shooting off on our own not so much. Which is why Paul goes ballistic with the Galatians as they seem to want to “go back to Egypt”, go back to the old structure, the old prison. Such a move would be fatal. It cuts you off from the true fountain of truth: The unmerited Grace God pours out through Christ. You can’t have it both ways.

What we see in “The Shawshank Redemption” (one of my all-time favorites) are lives in a particular kind of world, that of prison, with its walls and routines. Towards the middle of the movie Mr. Brooks, an institutional man of over 50 years, is finally set free on parole though no longer able to know how to live, how to be, without the walls around him, without his “στοιχεῖα.” His mindset is all institutional, not free. All he knows are the four prison walls, and the greater freedom of the other world is threatening. So, he either commits another crime to get back in to prison, or he kills himself. (No spoiler here).

Something similar is happening in “The Matrix”. The hardest thing for Neo (the protagonist) is to learn that the structure he is used to is an illusion that can be bent, transcended. Taking “the red pill” will help him see the “real” underlying structure and learn how to manipulate it. He must change his mindset. This turns out to be hard.

Paul in Galatians talks about the old structure in the law of Moses, the perfect adherence to which was possible for only one man, Christ, and not for anyone else. The law’s στοιχεῖα served to point to the one man who could observe it perfectly and did. The law is there to remind us of what is right in God’s eyes and how impossible it is for us to adhere to it. Through the perfect life of Christ, which the surrounding world could not tolerate but crucified, an avenue (a “red pill”?) was offered. Through faith in the One who did live perfectly and paid the price for all those who couldn’t, we can enter into the God-centered reality we are all called to, we enter into the mind of God. The Galatians did this gladly to start with, it seems, but were quickly perverted back to the old structure. Which shows us the power of the “world”.

Paul warns his flock not to return to the στοιχεῖα of Judaism with its rules and injunctions, its walls, but to pursue the freedom in Christ that comes from faith in His death and resurrection and not from whatever striving we could humanly accomplish. Human striving actually prevents us from entering the true reality and leaves us in our current, fallen state. It is in being “Faithers” like this that we further bear the image of God, where our worlds come to perfect harmony with Him in the power of the Holy Spirit. (See here)

An important example of this harmony is supposed to be marriage, which is why marriage is so central in God’s world. Husband and wife, in mutual submission to one another, bring their worlds into perfect harmony with each other through love and thus in harmony with God. The ultimate in image-bearing. Or, they are supposed to. As a contradistinction, we see the pain and heartache there is in strife, separation, divorce and death. Where worlds clash and disrupt rather than harmonize. The passing-on of my parents, for example,  brought grief when the worlds they created were no longer with us. I saw it first in my mother as dad passed, and she had a really hard time reorienting herself to the new reality. Then my mom passed and we grieved again through the funeral and the dismantling of the home where my parents’ world, and mine, had been. The question is: Do we adhere to the basic, elementary principles of the worlds we can create, with their stuff and routines, or do we take the “Red Pill”, faith in Christ, and orient our worlds with God’s world? The latter is risky, it requires FAITH. The freedom that the world of faith offers entails risk: Not knowing, taking a chance, not being afraid, stepping out. It might (and most often does) entail privation, pain, suffering. In Shawshank, we see this in Red, a fellow prisoner with Andy, who does so, little by little, and winds up on a beautiful, sunny beach. We see it in Job too.

Ultimately, we see it in Jesus who risked it all. He knew where the journey would end up and the calamities along the way. And yet, He had the temerity to persevere, endure and conquer. At the ultimate loss, the ultimate sacrifice He did not hide his face (Isiah 50:6). He was the ultimate “Faither”. The question is: Do we have the faith, the mindset to step out and take the risk? Do we embrace the mindset, the faith that God puts before us or do we foolishly cling to the στοιχεῖα we create ourselves and wind up in all sorts of grief as Andy did that rainy night in the car, a bottle of whiskey in one hand and a 30-ought revolver in the other outside the house with his unfaithful wife and her lover. Or, do we polish the shoes, press the suit and hammer away at the wall…

Even abject misery can be defeated by hope, by love. Meaning can be derived from the meanest of circumstance (Frankl, 1984). In the end, God’s truth will set you free (John 8:32), though hardship might be necessary to learn how to tolerate that freedom, to gain the mindset necessary to see God’s world for what it is, to tolerate the power that God will pour out in our hearts.

As it was in the beginning, is now and ever shall be: World without end.

Previous
Previous

Simu-WHAT?

Next
Next

Further down the rabbit trail