Simu-WHAT?

AI is all the rage. From the bright shining hope of humanity’s salvation to the monster in the closet that’ll eat us alive (or at least eat our jobs). Oh, so much handwringing, ink-spilling, investment-consuming, sleep-losing with this new technology, it makes your head spin. But, it’s here. Kind of. Odd that all the investment hasn’t generated the earth-shattering changes people have foreseen. Might have something to do with the lack of energy?

Anyway, we have to get used to it. One of the more interesting folks writing on this is David Chalmers. In his 2022 book “Reality+” he takes us on a journey through thought experiments on what this technology can and might do. (If you read this book remember that these are all THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS and not yet reality. Chalmers seems to get confused on that at times). In particular, Chalmers is interested in virtual worlds and simulations. Not to put too fine a point on it, he wants to speculate on what it would be like to live in an immersive virtual world or even embed human consciousness in a computer for eternal life (provided eternal power to the computing device supporting it, one would suppose).

But let’s think about this for a moment, just to try to put it in some real-life context.

Currently, in order to get a computer screen to display a text output of some AI algorithmic answer to a question, these new whizz-bang AI entities need data centers the size of football fields, preferably attached to their own nuclear reactor for power. Compare that to the world-making “machines” that already exist (us humans) that do this kind of thing while walking and chewing gum at the same time. We do this with a “device” the size of a small melon (our brains) housed in a body that neatly fits into an average chair, powered by a bowl of cornflakes. The difference in scale and efficiency is staggering. The amount of energy needed to get a computer to do something that a 5-year old can do after a quick nap is simply mind boggling. Even if we projected massive improvements in power consumption, availability, transmissibility and utilization, the thought that we’ll be able to get “human like” robot avatars that are indistinguishable from real humans in every respect, let alone entire worlds indistinguishable from the one we actually have is preposterous, to say the least. You do the math.

Let’s take this one step further (or maybe two): Take an entity that can do this kind of thing on a scale of billions of entities simultaneously, on perhaps billions of worlds scattered across billions of galaxies: That would be God. Imagine the power! Certainly not to be trifled with. One would think.

Simulate THAT!

Previous
Previous

Leaping Faith

Next
Next

A free man on a long journey