Free Will

The relationship of our free will (agency) and God’s Sovereignty is a tricky one to wrap one’s head around. This is so probably because we, as finite and limited creatures, are trying to grasp something divine, i.e.: Out of our reach. That said, I think a significant issue is that we are operating with some false assumptions about “freedom” on the one hand and the “Sovereignty or Will of God” on the other. This is obviously a BIG subject, wrangled over for millennia, but I’ve solved it… (big chuckle here ;-)

What do we mean by “freedom”? Self-determination amongst a range of choices seems to be the main feature. Part of the problem here is that we want to envision a self-determination like you might conceive of in a universe without God. Or, put another way, we want to conceptualize a universe that is a neutral, pre-existing and otherwise non-created thing in which other things exist and events happen, possibly including God and whatever He does, but certainly including us and whatever we do. So, our concept of “freedom” is intimately connected with our concept of ourselves and our concept of the universe we seem to inhabit.

On the issue of the “self”, I’ll have to punt (for the most part) to later post. However, both of these concepts have morphed significantly over the centuries of human thought. Charles Taylor (2007) describes post-enlightenment changes in detail. In short, we moderns have inherited a concept of the universe as some neutral, pre-existing and otherwise non-created stage upon which history unfolds, (But, see Klavan 2024 on how modern theoretical physics does violence to this enlightenment heritage) and us humans as “buffered” (as opposed to spiritually “porous”) beings that stumble around on this stage. Taylor describes this kind of universe as disenchanted, ie: godless, but open to whatever manipulation seems desirable.

One feature of this disenchanted universe is that it makes no sense to conceive of God existing in such a universe. If God is God, absolutely self-sufficient and self-determining, then there can be nothing outside of Him that is independent of Him. The universe cannot exist independently of and extrinsic to God. So, if the universe is extrinsic and independent of a god, then god does not exist. But we are then left with not only the question of where this universe came from, but also the question of whether it makes sense to talk about strictly material objects (us, no matter how complex) as having autonomy within a deterministic universe? If we are evolved creatures that are materially determined and simply responding to environmental stimuli, then what becomes of the concept of “freedom”? I recall discussing this with Patricia Churchland shortly after she published her book Neurophilosophy (1986), where she argues for a strictly materialist conceptualization of mind in a strictly material universe. Her response was: No, if the universe is pre-existent and humans are simply biological machines, then we are indeed constrained and not the free agents we think we are. There is no “responsibility”, “guilt”, “freedom” (See a later reformulation in Churchland 2019). We would have to re-define those concepts. Hence, it seems that “absolute freedom” is not possible even in a purely material universe. The “problem” of freedom with God goes away, but not really the way we’d like.

Then the question becomes, is it even conceivable that there be a universe without God to create it? As we’ve seen above, a purely material universe does not give us the freedom we want. But may it not be the universe that actually is? There are many conceptualizations of where a godless universe might come from, so far none of them provable scientifically. String theory is one attempt where super-dimensional “branes” (derived from “membrane”) oscillate eternally in spacetime and create universes wherever branes touch one another in an interaction of energy- and gravitational fields (Rovelli 2017). But these “explanations” simply beg the question: Where did the branes and fields come from? This does not seem to me to settle anything. Of course, the same is true of positing an eternal, unmade God, but at least the reductio ad absurdum ends somewhere and ends with an active, creative agent. Lots of us feel unsatisfied with this “explanation” though, as we’ve seen, the materialist one isn’t really any better, at least as far as freedom is concerned.

(Just as an aside, I can’t help but chuckle at materialists who really lose it with any talk of a “pre-existing and otherwise non-created” God but have no qualms about accepting a “neutral, pre-existing and otherwise non-created” material universe. I guess the real rub is with “neutral”, with something “pre-existing and otherwise non-created” that might actually care about what we do. But more on that in a later post…)

So, what of our concept of freedom? We all understand that there can be no “absolute freedom”. I cannot fly like a bird, at least not for very long. It is not in my nature to be able to fly like that. I can, however, run, jump, swim, walk and even fly in planes I create. So, I have sufficient freedom within constraints to be able to freely choose from within a range of choices, though not “absolute freedom” as usually conceived in secular discourse.

So, if we discuss human freedom within the context of a God-given universe, ie: one that has some constraints, we first have to accept that there is no freedom without God. Most basically because without God there is nothing. But because there is God what exists exists and does whatever is in their (God given) natures to do. In addition to that “intrinsic” constraint, there would be the additional constraint of God’s “will”. If He ordains everything from the get-go, what freedom do I have? So, does it make sense to talk about freedom in this context?

And this is where it breaks down for some people. As mentioned, we all recognize limits to our freedom. But what gets some people is the concept of moral guilt or responsibility. If God ordains what is, why am I held responsible for my choices? Well, although I can’t derive energy from sunlight and CO2 like plants can, I do have a choice of what I eat to fuel myself. If I eat only certain things (McDonalds, for example) then I’ll have a heart-attack and die. If I eat the right kind of stuff, then maybe I won’t. Am I not responsible for my health because I can’t photosynthesize? Of course I am. And from a juridical perspective, constraints on choice does not remove choice nor the responsibility for and consequence of such choices. Scripture is clear: There are choices to be made. Obey or not. The consequences are also clearly spelled out: obey and have joy, disobey and die. But does God not ordain that I disobey? If God chooses some and not others, is it really their fault if they disobey? I think it’s here that we start asking questions above our paygrade. But Scripture seems clear here as well, that there are choices, and God lets us have them. Since He is omniscient, He “chooses” those He knows will, of their own free will, choose to disobey. And in this foreknowledge, He knows how His enterprise will unfold, BECAUSE of our freedom to choose within our own context within His will.

I think we also have a much too rigid concept of the “Sovereignty and Will of God”, and I suspect it is roomier, more elastic, than we think. I will not thwart the Parousia if I park in the “wrong” parking spot at church any given Sunday. I can choose from a range of choices and still be within the “Sovereignty and Will of God”. In fact, ALL my choices turn out to be so. And still, they are MY choices.

So, it seems to me that a divinely created and upheld universe with constrained but sufficiently autonomous agents is the most logical solution to these questions and there is really no conflict between a creator God with Divine agency and human freedom, provided we understand the limits of the constructs. But then: To short circuit it all: There was this guy in Palestine who died on a cross and rose again… Seems to say something important, that.

Previous
Previous

Jesus and freedom

Next
Next

And the Lord said…