Jesus and freedom

A friend of mine asked me: Is/was it possible for Jesus to sin? If it isn’t/wasn’t, then He is/was not free, and therefore not human. First off, we must hold that to be human cannot entail “absolute” freedom since there is no such thing, at least not for us. So, it is obviously possible to be human even if one is not “absolutely” free. We do, after all, exist. Second, we must be clear on what it is “to sin”. Per definition this would be to contravene God’s laws and purposes (or try to). God cannot contravene his own laws/purposes and still be God. Hence, He cannot sin. Nor can God the Son. And yet, it makes no sense to even think of an absolutely self-determining being such as God sinning. What would that be? God does what God does. If He were to contravene Himself He would not be God. The proposition is absurd.

But was Jesus truly human if He couldn’t give in to sin and fall? Was pre-fall Adam human? I would say so. So, it was possible for humans to not sin prior to the fall, though is no longer so after the fall, this is part of the curse: Humans are no longer able to “not sin”. Jesus as the second (pre-fall) Adam lived a truly free life because he was not enslaved to sin and destined to eternal death. Yet He was still human, as Adam was human.

But in a way, Jesus did sin, or, rather, He became sin, for us (2 Cor 5). He took upon himself the sin of the world, becoming more sinful than any one of us, but through death and resurrection, He conquered the curse of sin. Just how that works is beyond me, but for those who believe and put their trust in Him, he grants the right to become children of God (John 1:12).

Previous
Previous

Dawkins’ delusion

Next
Next

Free Will