Letter on a plane

D…

So, I’m sitting on the plane to Miami and it turns out that the book I brought to read “Comparative studies on how people think” was actually NOT on how people think but on HOW to do research, get funding and publish on cross-cultural language studies. Oh well, ought to learn me about getting stuff off Amazon sight unseen! Anyhow, this lapse gave me an opportunity to watch through the video on Peterson and Poststructuralism. And glad I did. A very thought-provoking video and provided lots of food for thought. Thanks for sharing. I’d like to share a few thoughts, if you don’t mind stuff from a non-technical non-philosopher. I wish we could kick this around over a bottle of wine. This, what I am writing here, is going to be a bit loose, being on the plane and all, and from a non-philosopher, but I hope you can bear with me!

I guess the first thing to think about is: Is it legitimate for a non-philosopher to criticize a philosopher, or a philosophical idea, or the perception of the idea or the suspected outcome of a certain (philosophical) train of thought. I know something of your views on “voter responsibility”, to call it that, and, surely, there must be a spectrum of “legitimate competency” if you will. On one end there is unmitigated, even malicious, ignorance that I guess should be disqualified out of hand. On the other, there may be super-informed expertise that is so narrow as to be practically useless. Then something in the middle. We’ve talked about this before and you seem to suggest that the benevolent ignoramus may be the preferred actor. Still, some level of enlightenment seems to be required, but where does one draw the line? Peterson is certainly not totally ignorant. He is not trying to disqualify poststructuralists by arguing that they are a bunch of Buddhist transcendentalists (though Foucault certainly was). Peterson IS trying to engage them on the substance of their theories, as far as Peterson understands them as a psychologist and not as a philosopher. Although he certainly opines on things as IF he were a philosopher, though I wonder if that disqualifies him? You have raised concerns about his integrity and I have to admit I don’t know enough about him to say.

OK, so Peterson misunderstands at least some of Poststructuralist positions, or at least seems to, though his interlocutor here (I forget his name, Michael? Let’s call him M) clearly misunderstands Peterson, or at least misses Peterson’s overall concern. But first: I think what I saw here was a classic example of two ships passing in the night, two people talking past each other, something easy to do on the internet like this. I see Peterson trying to take a 30000-foot perspective and M is criticizing him for not using a microscope (or, maybe more to the point, of not knowing HOW to use a microscope, - at 30000 feet). It also strikes me a bit odd to criticize someone for being piecemeal in their approach and flippant/emotional (teary-eyed) in their delivery by providing piecemeal video clips with a flippant tone… But, that is more on style than substance.

My take on Peterson’s concern is very much in line with what Charles Taylor talks about in “A Secular Age” (2007): How our “Social Imaginary” has evolved since the enlightenment. Maybe Peterson has picked up a bunch of ideas from Taylor? IDK. But, it seems clear to me, that Peterson’s concern is how Poststructuralism HAS “infiltrated” society. Having read Taylor (2007), Phil Rieff (2006), some Foucault (1984, no primary Derrida alas, only about him) and Karl Trueman (2020) on the same subject, and with knowledge of Freud and his descendants, history, etc, there DOES seem to be a very clear line (following Taylor) from Enlightenment secularization of the cosmos into a neutral universe (Isaac Newton), rebellion against oppressive social structures (Rousseau) to a analytic (decomposition) of the self (Freud), to a Poststructuralist deconstruction of knowledge and language (Derrida) and society (Foucault) in terms of laying bare (latent, vertical) power structures in networks of relationships (vertical and horizontal). The emergence of identity politics seems to me clearly in line with the developments that Taylor outlines and that Peterson suggests.

Now, whether or not the Poststructuralists are merely descriptive in an attempt to innovate in our understanding of ourselves (possibly) or more deliberately proscriptive (not unlikely) in the sense that Bolshevism is a proscriptive “perversion” of Marxist theory or, likewise, National Socialism is a proscriptive perversion of Nietzsche, becomes irrelevant IF the further evolution of Poststructuralist ideas/theories leads to social decomposition, however unintended. To say that there is no “infiltration” of these ideas seems ludicrous to me when one can get sued for “mis-gendering” someone, or be forced to fabricate DEI statements in order to become employed (at least as an academic)! To dismiss such currents as fads is to miss Taylor’s point entirely. Quite apart from the inanity of much of contemporary political correctness, the insidious aspect is that these “fads” are indeed assuming coercive force in that they are designed to compel behavior and change “society”, in a very broad sense of “society”. Hence, M’s “flippant” comment that we should not be afraid of dead French philosophers is disingenuous. We should indeed be concerned about their ideas/theories. There clearly IS a militant wing of this “movement” that DOES seek to blow things up. There is a clear appreciation that modern critical theory (in large part queer, as the most outré member of the group) MUST be transgressive and disruptive in its very nature and practice in order to BE queer. The whole point is to overthrow the oppressive power structures that Poststructuralism has revealed and that has led to this repressive “vertical” logophalloheterocentric normativity (I made that one up!). Now, we may say GOOD RIDDANCE to said normativity, yet I am not persuaded that the alternative is any more attractive, ultimately. One is simply substituting one power structure with another.

All that said, I agree that M’s critique of Peterson’s understanding of logophallocentrism, hierarchies, marginalization, etc is spot on, though, as I said to begin with, I think the two are really talking past each other, or at least on different plains. One area where I think M is wrong, is where he tries to defend Poststructuralism (at least Derrida, of whom M seems to know a whole lot more than of Foucault) in terms of literary criticism not trying to remove “purpose” from the “book”, giving writings on moral philosophy as an example. I think this, though brief, argument really misses the Poststructuralist enterprise entirely. Certainly, if you read Foucault (as I just did on being an “author”) it is immediately clear that the Poststructuralist stance is that there is NO authorial intent, one can’t even talk about authorial intent at all. Since all language/knowledge resides in a complex network of presuppositions, interpretation, (power)structures. Meaning evaporates or didn’t really exist to begin with. Much in the same sense that quantum mechanical foundations are in their very nature indeterminate (viz Heisenberg) not just exhaustively immeasurable. (Probably a bad example of what I mean). I DO think Peterson is on track, though clumsy, when he tries to describe how the individual “disappears” in the process of deconstructing the power structures of networks of relationships. Sartre introduces “Being and nothingness” with a discussion of how who we ARE actually IS what people think/say we are and nothing else/more. See also CS Lewis (1943) on the “Abolition of man”.

So, anyway, I’m not really trying to defend Peterson as much as I am trying to wrap my head around our current philosophical and social predicament. My tack has been historical, following Taylor (after Trueman, 2020). I’ve got a lot more to read and assimilate, though I do find it all disturbing and quite personal, as I am sure Peterson does, given his training and research. It is hard to look at the slippery slope we’re on and NOT be concerned, even though there are lots of voices trying to convince us there are no slippery slopes. I hope you can tolerate a dilatant like me.

BTW, I also watched that debate between Stacy Kagan and whatshisname on “Do we need to have God to have morals”. This solidified in my mind that the devil is really not in the details (as commonly assumed) but in the assumptions. Kagan assumes a universe without God (or at least possibly so) while the other guy assumes there is one. The real question is: If there is/no God, then what? Could we construct some kind of moral system without recourse to a deity? Maybe. Though the scholastics would argue strongly (and I think successfully) that ANY rule requires a rule-giver. The law of non-contradiction is nowhere inscribed on the fabric of the universe (assuming a post-enlightenment neutral universe), which, furthermore, is not of necessity transparent to our understanding. And Nietzsche has argued strongly for the consequences of the death of God, bourgeoise beware! But, that is a discussion for another day…

Hope you are well, my son. Love you so much

Dad

Previous
Previous

Lament for a loved one.

Next
Next

SLAVERY