Dear S
I feel for you and wish I had the words that could comfort and encourage. Apparently, I don’t. I am sorry. Yet I will sit with you on your mourning bench anyway.
It is a hard thing you do, grappling with deep loss. I’ve thought much about this. If there is a God, why create a world with so much suffering? It makes no sense, at least at first blush. And yet, what if there is no God? What if we are all madmen running through the marketplace screaming, “God is dead, God is dead?” Does suffering miraculously disappear? I suspect in that case, suffering actually gets worse, it becomes truly meaningless and we are all reduced to being bonobos staring at cave-wall shadows.
But it is here, I think, the central point in Woltersdorff’s (1987) message lies: Yes, life is brutish, cold and hard, yet there IS hope, there IS Joy. It lies in a God who not only suffers with us, who suffers FOR us. The true weight of suffering in the world is more than any of us can bear. Only God can bear it, and He does. Christ in Gethsemane pleaded for the cup to pass him by. The answer was “no”, there is no other way. For there to be the world where the creature and the Creator can live in intimate Joy together, this is how it must be. So, Christ DID bear the full weight of suffering in the world and conquered it! THIS is what provides genuine hope and joy, because there is a God to lay hold on, a God who suffers for us and with us. Those who suffer are blessed, because they have better access to this hope and joy than the rest of us who, through our lack of suffering, delude ourselves with the false peace of complacency.
But this too is hard. It is hard to understand, because it really doesn’t answer the question “why?”. And yet, who said we are entitled to such answers? Is it not hubris to feel so entitled? Can the pot really demand an explanation from the potter, “why did you make me thus”? There is a song bouncing around in my head with the refrain: “You have all you need, so why do you ask for more?” (See 2 Peter 1:3) It humbles me to tears that God condescends to speak to us at all. Not only that, He does lift the veil, He does invite us in, and what we can see is glorious.
Be at Peace. I pray this journey you are on will lead to true happiness and contentment. I am glad we have a means to commiserate with one another.
Please forgive my ramblings if they miss the mark, but I felt a burden to speak, as we sit here.
J