Cogito 2.?

So, I’m really trying to wrap my head around this thing here. With all the brain and computer power we have at our disposal you’d think we’d be able to sort this out pretty quick. But, see my post on “Enlightenment Hubris” and “Sorcerer’s apprentice”. Let me share some of my confusion with you!

Descartes’s famous Cogito “I think, therefore I am” served as the bedrock of his epistemology, and a springboard for all subsequent enlightenment thinking. Seems to me our glorious evolution as sapient creatures has morphed this dictum into something hardly recognizable as any kind of principle for understanding anything: “I feel therefore I am”, or rather:

Cogito 2.5: “I feel, that is what I am”, regardless of any external reality anyone could point to with any reliability. To wit: There seems to be some kind of disconnect between the body and the “self” so that the two can, in fact, be in conflict with one another.

However, it seems inconceivable to me that we can alter the body without changing the self at all. We have a body where each and every cell is demonstrably yoked to its internal (and external) environment. I’ve kicked this around a few times, but to keep things simple: Let’s use “self” as a placeholder for this thing that thinks it is something (and is unhappy about the given state of affairs), “cell” as a placeholder for the genetic makeup and “env” as a placeholder for the bodily environment. Let’s further broaden this to be a bit less deterministic and assume there is some other factor that contributes to this picture. Let’s call it “F”. We would then have the traditional understanding:

1)    XY-cell + XY-env + F => XY-self

and so on. So, let’s assume that this said “XY-self” firmly perceives that there is something somehow “wrong” with this construct, ie:

2)    XY-cell + XY-env + F ≠> XY-self 

But instead

3)    XY-cell + XY-env + F => XX-self

or some other permutation. Let’s call it “??-self”. We then have:

4)    XY-cell + XY-env + F => ??-self ≠ XY-self 

The further assumption, then, is that we can alter things, notably the XY-env (as we can’t change XY-cell and we have no idea what F is) to suit the perceived ??-self:

5)    XY-cell + XX-env + F = > ??-self

But it seems unreasonable to assume that ??-self will actually remain the same through changing the construct. We know there are dependencies between XY-cell, XY-env and ??-self. Certainly XY-env depends in large part on XY-cell and the ??-self is clearly embodied after all, that is why things need to change, this seems implicit in the whole drive for the change. So, at best, we have the following construct:

6)    XY-cell + XX-env + F = > ??*-self

The question then becomes, how can:

7)    ??*-self = ??-self

Given what we actually know about biology, psychiatry, etc. we would have to conclude

8)    XY-cell + XX-env + F => ??*-self ≠ ??-self

But we have already noted that the whole issue is

9)    ??*-self ≠ ??-self ≠ XY-self.

This would then have to be discordant and hence dysphoric since the ??*-self is clearly not the ??-self that was desired. We are actually back to step 2. This would then entail further intervention to assuage this new (and clearly different) dysphoria. But where could this possibly end?

Of course, none of this makes any sense. Our minds are clearly embodied. There are clear connections and dependencies between mind, self and body as I mentioned above, and the insistence that the “XY-cell + XY-env + F” be altered to suit the ??-self in the first place entails such a connection. If there was no connection, then the alteration would be unnecessary. Unless -- there is something “wrong” with the ??-self and not XY-cell, XY-env or F. This, at least, is where the psychiatric community was firmly rooted prior to Stonewall and why the tinkering with the DSM caused such a furor at the time. But that was grounded in a Freudian structuralism, which, as we know, is DEAD,  DAMN IT, DEAD!

Alternatively, there could be something embedded in this mysterious “F” that makes the logic actually work out. Though we have no idea what “F” is or how it relates to the rest of the construct, and so seems like a pure deus ex machina.

So, it seems to me that the real issue lies with the ??-self and we should really be looking to “correct” the “wrong” that is there, rather than jump down a bottomless, post-modern rabbit hole into wonderland where the sorcerer’s apprentice can never actually design the perfect construct. Oh, well. We’re back where we started…

Sic transit gloria mundi.

Previous
Previous

Death

Next
Next

Lament for a loved one.