The sorcerer’s apprentice

A question was put to me: Should we try to resurrect an extinct wolf from fossilized DNA? Of course, “Jurassic Park” immediately sprang to mind and the answered seemed obviously “NO”. Well, “Hell NO” actually. But then the real question quickly became apparent: To what degree should we tinker with nature and the way we interact with it, - at all? For example, from recent research it seems clear that well-meaning advice from the pediatric community about step wise introduction of food stuffs to infants may actually have precipitated the nut allergies we experience today. Such allergies do not exist in other parts of the world where nuts are consumed early in life and in great quantities. Sanitizing our environment seems related to the massive uptick in auto-immune disorders. If the body has no external invader to attack it seems it will start attacking itself. In former days, 9/10 doctors smoked Camels (or so we’re told). Bleeding was once a cure-all. Trephination was also practiced. On the other hand, we have eradicated small pox and almost polio (though give RFK a chance and we’ll have all that back, with a vengeance).  Today, physicians counsel everything from eating particular oils and vegetables to keep cholesterol low to cutting off body parts to optimize health, whether that be appendectomies for infections or gender reassignment surgeries if one is borne in the “wrong body”. When do we actually know enough to know that what we do is really a good idea? I have personally treated patients with the most up to date technologies and knowledge in my field, often with spectacular results. Sometimes not… So, where do we draw the line? Are there lines to be drawn? Transhumanism any one?

Seems to me that intervening with the “natural” course of things is within our stewardship mandate, to fill the earth and subdue it (Gen 1:28). Yet, fools rush in where angels fear to tread (I guess that’s really about romantic love, but the principle still holds). We CAN actually measure things and figure out risks/benefits, but, to be honest, the vast majority of what we do, either as scientist, health care providers or lay people, do not come with a robust specification sheet to inform us of pros and cons. Most of the time we have to do the best we can with limited knowledge. Medicine has a foundational principle: “Sine non nocere”, above all do no harm. Problem is, if we did not take risks, we would gain very little, so we do take risks.

So, what about the extinct wolf? What could possibly go wrong? Well, lots. In my mind, extinction is for a reason, survival also. What is is and what isn’t should probably stay that way. Maybe there are certain foundational processes we should leave well enough alone? Like bringing back organisms that have not proven to fit well with our current environment? As with the germ line, that lies at the heart of our (or any) species? As with the fundamental mechanisms of organismal vitality (eg: gain of function genetic modification in respiratory viruses. COVID anyone?). Maybe the more fundamental, the more critical, the more dangerous the intervention, maybe forebear? To paraphrase Cormac McCarthy (Border Trilogy) “Just because something can be doesn’t mean it’s a good idea”.

Further to the point, though, I think a lot of the stuff we do is aimed at prolonging our stay here in this world, making this world “better” (for whatever purpose one has I mind). Once we realize that this world is not all there is, that there is something greater that we really should be aspiring to and that the things that happen to us here, for better or for “worse”, is actually to prepare us for this greater world, we would then realize that maybe we shouldn’t be messing with as much as we tend to want to mess with! Instead, maybe we should embrace the world as it unfolds to us, possibly with simple, common-sense interventions, and rather look forward to what God is calling us to do and be.

And let God be God.

Previous
Previous

Transjordan

Next
Next

Chicken crossings, Fowl humor: “A Cluckwork Orange”