It’s been almost 4 months since my last post! WOW, talk about writer’s block. Some vacation too, though. I’ve determined to get back on track and continue the journey. We’ll see how that turns out. The spring and summer (now early fall) brought some good travel and time for reflection, all of which should be good fodder for the blog going forward.
I’ve put up a new picture series you can fond here. There are new photos occasionally in any of the series, always placed first for easy browsing of new stuff. I’ll write more about that in subsequent posts.
But, I wanted to continue where I left off in the spring, with worlds we make and how we orient ourselves to them. This is a huge area for study, so big in fact that it is hard to know where to start and can lead you down rabbit-holes if you are not careful. But I think it is important to think about this as “selves”, personhood, “human-ness” is really THE issue of the day. Can we really deconstruct our realities and be whatever we want, this or that, or fluidly in whatever direction? Who are we, really, and if there is a God, what is He up to with all this? As I discussed here, I’ve always been the annoying kid who asks “why”. More often enough with trouble to follow rather than answers.
But as I ponder all this, a few things seem clear to me:
1) All things must spring from the mind of God and be within His sovereignty, or He is not God.
2) There is nothing outside God. Hence, we cannot speak of God “residing in” a world. The world resides in Him.
3) All things that are not God are created by God.
4) All created things change. Heraclitus was only partially right: You can’t step into the same river twice not only because new waters are ever flowing, but the riverbed is always changing and the person stepping into the changing river is also changing. When we talk about identity over time we have to account for change. Only God does not change.
5) The purpose of this whole changing cosmos is to raise up living stones to adopt into the family of God, to expand His triune fellowship with the Son and the Spirit.
6) God creates a cosmos that not only adheres to His sovereign will but also has sufficient agency and autonomy to act with sufficient freedom to be culpable when not acting in accordance with God’s precepts, though cannot be said to be “absolutely free”. Absolute freedom exists only for God as the only self-sufficient being. The cosmos and us humans are simply free enough.
7) What springs from the mind of God is real, has material substance as far as material substance can go within the mind of God. Here I think Bernardo Kastrup (2024) is on to something: Idealism is not dead and substance dualism (and naïve realism in its most basic form) has real problems (see #17 below). It simply doesn’t jive with what we experience and doesn’t pencil out as a coherent system, epistemologically or ontologically. Neither does cold naturalism. A friend of mine has a nice piece here on how naturalism is metaphysically bankrupt. (Which of course does not bother the naturalist who thinks there is no metaphysic anyhow. But, more on that another time.)
8) An idealist world springing from the mind of God is no less real than the alternatives. Here I think David Chalmers (2022) is on to something: a) “Virtual” (ie: created) entities are as real and substantive as anything. b) Virtual/created entities can have agency with as much independence as is programmed/created into them. c) Being in a perfectly created world (“a perfect simulation” in Chalmer’s terms) means you can never know whether you are in one or not.
9) God’s creation reflects his nature. As Leibniz points out, God doesn’t contradict Himself, He doesn’t create crap, or, pari-passu, God does not allow anything to happen that does not serve His purpose. Hence, God does not contradict Himself by violating the nature of the nature He creates. Now, our “laws of nature” may be violated in so far as those laws, springing from our own minds and not God’s, might be wrong. But I would submit that when Jesus walks on water, He is not suspending any God-ordained law of Gravity, He simply knows all about gravity and surface tension of water so He can manipulate them as He sees fit. We do not.
10) God creates entities such as us humans with definitive structures and purposes, with what we discern as body parts. Yes, I can still be “me” without my appendix, or an arm or whatever, but I am not the same “me” as I was when I had them, though the difference without them might be small. We are not meat Legos (Harrington 2023). I cannot ever be a “brain-in-a-vat”, nor can you embed “me” in a computer simulation (condolences to Peter Thiel). I can only be “me” as the aggregate of the parts that constitute me in the context that contains me.
11) So even though I start off as a simple sperm-fertilized egg and develop from there, there is an inherent structure in me throughout that allows me to be the same “me” through change. What this structure is, is a big hairy question.
12) God creates lots of us because a main purpose we serve is to relate to one another and to Him at a number of different levels. We are not islands, nor are our body parts exhaustively interchangeable.
13) The body-part we call our brain is not an isolated or isolatable thing. It is not a computing device. There is no “hardware” that runs a “software” generating “outputs” from “inputs”. Although it is possible to describe at least part of the story this way, I believe it is incomplete, insufficient and fundamentally wrong. The brain is a relational entity that is designed to relate to a particular body (the rest of “me”) and other bodies (human or otherwise) and to the world around it. There are NO representations IN our brains. The representations the brain generates IS the “world out there”. This includes my brain’s relationship to itself. This is consciousness.
14) Other creations can have consciousness, only not human consciousness and certainly not my consciousness. This consciousness allows these creatures whatever level of autonomy and agency they can have, given their structure. Humans are endowed with a unique level of agency and autonomy that far outstrips any other creature. Finding human-like agency in other creatures does not make them identical or even equivalent to humans. While crows can use rocks as hammers, they will never beat out a golden calf, let’s say. Pari-Passu, if we can make a computer that appears to be conscious (satisfies the Turing test) it will never have “human” consciousness. It is not possible.
15) So, we cannot slice, dice, scan, stimulate, drug or otherwise manipulate brains in isolation to find out the totality or even essence of who we are as persons. A brain-in-a-vat will never be a person. We are embodied creatures in a world with other creatures that are all changing over time and destined for a particular purpose: To love God and enjoy him forever.
16) The structures of these embodied selves determine, at least in part, the kind of essence, agency, independence and ability that the embodied self can have. Dogs are likely conscious, though they are unlikely to have a conscience. A dog will never feel guilty, though it can enjoy and suffer.
17) JP. Moreland likes to talk about our physical bodies being “earth suits” that enables our immortal souls to live an earth much like “space suits” enable astronauts to live in space. The problem with this idea is that there is no evidence for any way that the immaterial soul would interact with the material body. We see no “soul receptors” anywhere in the brain/body nor does neuropsychology see much evidence for the effect of spirit on body (apart from a very few studies suggesting an independent effect of prayer on medical outcomes). Sir John Eccles (a neurophysiologist) speculated that the stochastic nature of synaptic transmission would offer an avenue for the interaction of the spirit with body. I have had a similar notion regarding the stochastic nature of activity states in neural networks, though, so far, there is no empiric data to support either notion. So, there is an ontological as well as epistemological problem here. I find an idealist approach much better suited to explain what we see. Bernardo Kastrup (2024) has argued strongly for what he calls “analytic idealism”, where he takes Plato’s cave-allegory and simply defines the shadows on the cave wall as “reality”. If all springs from the mind of God, then this is not a bad metaphor. Seen in conjunction with David Chalmer’s (2022) work on simulations and virtual worlds, then I think a more coherent framework emerges. We need to see the brain not as a stand-alone computational device but as an integral part of a large, relational network springing from the mind of God as an expression of His divine creative energy and Love. The soul is connected to the brain which is connected to the body which is connected to the community which is connected to the world which is connected to history and the outworking of God’s Telos. So, when Scripture speaks of God creating a new heaven and a new earth, He is re-imagining (in the sense of His creation bearing His image, Gen 2) a new “simulation” where he recreates His followers as living stones in the body of Christ. Forever.