I’m on my way home from The Old Country where we buried my mom (more on that later) and after a very long trip I had time for a pint of good ol’ west coast IPA (how I missed you!) during my last lay-over in Portland. Interesting to see everybody around the bar with their noses in their iPhones. Not me! My nose is in a book (you know, that thing with print on paper where you have to turn the pages and maybe underline a thing or two? OK, so I date myself…) Anyhow, the book I’m reading is David Chalmers “Reality+” (2022). I hope to write more on that book in a bit, because I think he is really on to something, at least in metaphorical sense, that captures some of my ideas about the life of faith (more on this later too).
What caught my attention, though, (and that prompted this post) was chapter 7, where he talks about god, arguments for the existence of god, and why he is an atheist. He clearly has a pretty good conception of god, religion (I won’t say faith) and describes key features of a supreme god (p125):
1) Creator
2) All powerful
3) All knowing
4) All good
But ends up explaining his decision to be an atheist as follows (p144):
“Even if the Abrahamic God exists, with all the god-like qualities of perfection, I will respect, admire, and even be in awe of him, but I won’t feel bound to worship him”
Wow. I find it hard to think of what to say to this. Faced with a supreme being not only far beyond what we are ourselves but the ultimate and sole self-determined being that exists, THIS we will not worship? How could you possibly not? I’ve thought about this some, having been engaged with the 4 horsemen of the new atheist apocalypse (Dawkins, Hitchins, Dennet, Harris – but see Eagleton 1997 and here and here): Science really has no problem whatever with the attributes of a god as Chalmers enumerates:
1) Creator – we see creative activity all the time
2) All powerful – think: Big Bang.
3) All knowing – think: Advanced alien races and super-smart computer programmers or AI even.
4) All good – well, a bit of a problem here, what is “all good”?
But there are some very important attributes that Chalmers neglects to mention:
5) Omnipresent – think: Dark matter
6) All loving – which is really different from “all good”. Problem here.
7) Worthy of worship – BIG problem here.
Chalmers even mentions this last attribute a bit later in the chapter (conveniently leaving it off his list of fundamentals). So, in essence, he’s saying that he won’t worship even a god worthy of worship, supposedly because there are no being worthy of worship. As an argument this is at least circular if not outright nonsensical and can only be hubris. As I show above, science has no problem with any of the divine attributes even clustering all of them in a single “entity”, - God. What it has a problem with is such an entity having something imperative to say about how we live our lives, about who we really are, what our destinies are supposed to be. What science, and I think most non-believers, has a problem with is worship, as Chalmers does. The simple reason for this is that we want to be gods ourselves. To use Freud’s formulation: we want to be our own fathers. Imagine the neuroses that result when this turns out to not be possible!
‘Abraham said, "If they do not listen to Moses and the Prophets, then they will not believe, even if a man were raised from death."’ (Luke 16:31). Here, we have someone (Chalmers) who does “listen” to Moses and the Prophets, can describe God perfectly well, and still does not believe, as Eagleton also evinced having “listened” and also did not believe. It’s not about evidence or the ability to enumerate or process the evidence, but about our preset/assumptions, in particular, our assumptions about ourselves as the ultimate arbitrator of truth and reality. It really is quite amusing to read Chalmers’ book, arguing that we are quite likely simulated beings in a simulated universe, “it-from-bit”, and still cling to this notion of self-determination in the face of a “simulator” who controls everything. Which leads me to a final observation:
As I mentioned above, a key problem in Chalmers’ definition of a divine god, worthy of worship, is the “All loving”. Loving to the point of giving His creation the freedom to believe in and obey Him or not, and to the point of dying on a cross to enable His wayward creatures to remain with Him (as opposed to the alternative). If this does not add up to “worthy of worship”, then nothing does.
And yet, I have to wonder: Are we to love and worship God because of His attributes, or for some other reason? Seems to me God is worthy of worship not because of His attributes but simply because He is God. It seems to me that true knowledge of God is to know that He deserves worship simply for who He is. His being God actually demands it. Worship is an inextricable component of knowing God. Remember Thomas, when confronted with the resurrected Christ: “My Lord and my God!”. If you are not worshiping God for simply being God or if you are worshiping Him because of His attributes, you don’t really know Him.
And He doesn’t “know” you.