The perennial question

Well, you got to hand it to the wizards of the web. From time to time something pops up as an “interesting” link when I’m browsing for something totally different. I forget what I was actually browsing for when the above video-link popped up, probably something fishing-or photo-related (HAH! Go figure!). So, there was no really good reason for some anonymous server-bot to serve me this video when I was looking for a pattern for a purple haze parachute Adam’s fly, or how to edit pixels in a photo to retouch it… But, this came up. And I’m glad it did.

Now, I’ll say right off, I am a great fan of Chris Hitchens. An unabashed gadfly, striking left or right (mostly right) as he saw justifiable. To wit: A fierce critic of abortion-on-demand, noting that a civilization that does not protect its most vulnerable members (the unborn) is not a civilization worth much, or worth living in, and an equally fierce critic of the establishment right and religion (Christianity in particular). So, as a member of the “four horsemen” of the “new” atheist apocalypse” (Richard Dawkins, Dan Dennet, Sam Harris and Hitchens), he was always rabid about expounding on how “God is not good” and “religion ruins everything”. Well, both are questionable assertions, the latter an historical confusion and the former something he is trying to debate in the clip above, where our little foray will presently go.

So, I think Professor Lennox, an Oxford mathematician, does present a good, Gospel-based refutation of the main issue, though, somewhat unfortunately, completely tangential to Hitchens’ argument. And that is not a bad thing, really, Lennox hits the true heart of the matter and avoids the smoke and mirrors characteristic of Hitchens’ argument. I would like to try a re-direct, to use a judicial term.

So, Hitchens’ argument is really three-fold and drearily antiquated, but what of that, it doesn’t seem to go away: The first part of his argument is based on time, the second aspect is the usual argument from evil and the third is the preposterousness of God correcting something through gruesome shenanigans in an obscure, dusty place . Combined they purport to show how ludicrous belief in a god really is: There cannot be a god if he allows evil to persist for such a long time and deal with it in such a gruesome way. The overall argument is really shaking one’s fist at God, which I have addressed HERE. But let us look at these three aspects of the argument and see how they simply evaporate:

Easy one first: Time. Hitchens makes a big deal out of the supposed 100K years of Homo sapiens’ existence in misery. Per Hitchens, it could well be way longer than that, but he’ll settle for 100K years as long enough for his purposes. So, the question, then, is how long is “too long”? Would a couple of generations of suffering be OK, but 5 too many? A year (a brief famine in the land, let’s say), a millennium? How does time really play into this? The apostle Paul deals with this directly: “For I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us.” Rom 8:18. And Paul knew suffering: “Three times I was beaten with rods, once I was pelted with stones, three times I was shipwrecked, I spent a night and a day in the open sea” (2 Cor 11:25), he was “stoned, dragged out of the city and left for dead” (Acts 14:19). Paul knew suffering, he also had a good idea about time, about eternity. How long is 100K years compared to eternity? Eternity is a very long time. Compared to it, 100K is nothing, literally. So, once you overcome a post-millennial, materialist-orient and self-absorbed perspective on time, the “momentary afflictions” of this world are really nothing. No one doubts eternity, even the most die-hard materialist will acknowledge that time stretches out forever in both directions (eternity-past and eternity-future), though a thermodynamic argument could be made that once the universe reaches maximum entropy, then time, really an expression of thermodynamic heat dissipation, ceases to be, forever... (??) Well, I’ll leave that for the theoretical physicists, but even for the universe to reach maximum entropy will take orders of magnitude greater time than 100K years, so the argument from time simply evaporates. Literally.

Then there is the (age-old) argument from evil: How can you believe in a God when there is evil in the world. Now, I will grant you without equivocation, that there is evil in the world, always have been, likely always will be (until Christ’s return that is). This, however, does not represent a logical argument against the existence of God: Provided there are other agents in the universe that can serve as the originators of evil. That would be us, Homo sapiens that Hitchens pitties so much. As I have touched on HERE and elsewhere, God has created a universe with independent agents capable of making their own decisions, and hence prone to screwing things up if they do not pay attention to the instructions that came with the universe they were bequeathed. (Review Genesis 1-3, for a summary). I think though, that Hitchens’ argument is more like this: Given the presence of evil (however it got here), belief in God less desirable (or palatable, or logical) than the belief there is no God. Well, really? What is the alternative? We are all simply randomly occurring clumps of quantum gravitational and quantum mechanical interactions (Rovelli 2017) in a “… universe we observe has precisely the properties we should expect if there is, at bottom, no design, no purpose, no evil, no good, nothing but blind, pitiless indifference.” To use Richard Dawkins terms. So, our job is to grow to maturity (~14-15 years of age), have as many offspring as physically possible (a dozen?), each one with no better chance of reproductively out-competing its neighbor, then die to get out of the way for the offspring’s marginal chance of continuing the pathetic process and disappear into the vast, entropic erasure of the cosmos.

Feel better now?

I thought not. When looked at it dispassionately, I would think that the existence of the Biblical, triune God provides a more coherent, plausible and dare I say, desirable, explanation for, well, everything. Of course it comes with a cost: You can’t barge ahead however you damn-well please. You are not the boss of yourself (Noble 2021), you have to submit to the God who does rule and will be glorified: “…so that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father.” (Phil 2:10-11). The kicker here, is that such submission is no loss, no shame, no limitation: “No, in all these things we are more than conquerors through him who loved us. For I am convinced that neither death nor life, neither angels nor demons, neither the present nor the future, nor any powers, neither height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God that is in Christ Jesus our Lord.” (Rom 8:37-39).

The third, and so far final, corruption of the “new” atheist thinking in this matter, as expressed by Hitchens in his presentation, is that God seemingly had to introduce a corrective measure in the unfolding of the world gone awry and that this correction entailed the “torture” of an itinerant holy man in an obscure corner of the Middle East. This betrays a number of things: 1) A complete lack of understanding of (salvation) history and the process of God’s unfolding plan. Yahweh worship antedates Abraham (viz: Melchizedek) and stretches back to creation (however you see that happening). 2) The cross is not a “corrective measure”, but a design feature that allows Homo sapiens to have freedom (which it exercises badly) and still be saved. And 3) The torture, which the condemnation and crucifixion of Jesus surely was, was no isolated, random thing, but the starkest reminder of what our total depravity and sinfulness really is like. WE deserved the cross. Our fundamental fallenness is as ugly as the crucifixion. Hitchens has the usual, secular outlook that “we’re really not all THAT bad”. The cross argues otherwise. Jesus took our depravity on himself out of Love for His creation in order to bring a particular kind of being into intimate fellowship with the triune God. The “new” atheists have it all backwards. As usual.

A final, important objection to the hard-nosed “honesty” of the “new” atheists (viz Dawkins above, this one’s for free): They are not actually being honest with you! They do NOT live what they preach. Nietzsche would go ballistic and smack them upside the head: You are NOT running naked through the marketplace like the good little evolutionary engines that you really are. You are NOT ruthlessly exercising your will to power as you should, but living inauthentic lives encased in an insipid Judeo-Christian ethic that is simply the weaker groups tool to stifle the stronger individual. WAKE UP! Friedrich would say. GET REAL! Yet the “new” atheists prefer to slumber in their self-deception.

So, I don’t think that the (new) atheist argument holds water, is more coherent or even more satisfying than the Christian argument for the existence of God and His power in our lives and in the universe. Surely, the argument from evil winds up bankrupt, simply because removing God from the equation does not make evil go away. It simply makes it thoroughly meaningless, and life thoroughly hopeless, for the majority of us who have to succumb to other’s will to power, and even to those who, for a moment are more successful in wielding their will to power. There is always a bigger fish. The argument from time is a non-starter (and really not independent of the argument from evil anyway) and they totally miss God’s creative/redemptive plan. You know how you keep a secret from the “new”atheists? You publish it. (Hint: It’s called the Bible). In addition, we have Professor Lennox’ tried and true Gospel argument. The only really question I have is WHY would one not want God? Why run away from such a gift, such promises, such power? It really boggles my mind.

“He is no fool who gives up what he cannot keep to gain what he cannot lose.” (Jim Elliot 1949)

Previous
Previous

Waterfalls

Next
Next

A tribute to Ansel Adams