Transhuman?

Well, it’s a new year and who knows what it will bring. With so much kerfuffle in the world it is hard to keep focus sometimes. One of the growing preoccupations nowadays is transhumanism. And not surprisingly so. With the explosive growth in computer power and AI, medical innovations like in-vitro gametogenesis and a growing postmodern, deconstructionist view of meat-Lego humanism (Harrington 2023) it’s no wonder transhumanist perspectives are on the rise. Of course, we are at great risk of playing the sorcerer’s apprentice here (see prior blog entry here ), so serious debate is surely warranted.

Now, to be sure: Transhumanism is not only possible, it is inevitable. For all of us! It’s called the resurrection. 1 Cor 15 goes into this in great detail. Paul explicates the great mystery of the ages: We will all be changed, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye. Those who are long dead and their individual atoms recycled into the biosphere (there’s a little Charlemagne in all of us) will be raised again with the persistent identity of who they were before! Now, Paul takes pains to explain that the resurrection body’s likeness to the previous body is similar to that of the tree to the seed from which it sprang. Identity over change, another eternal philosophical puzzle. But this is not so outlandish. Think on it: We all start as a fertilized egg, a single cell, that then grows and matures into a being that walks and talks and creates and loves and … A being with agency, creativity, freedom, intelligence. “Transhumanism” is obviously more common than we think!

Only problem is: Do we think WE can do this kind of thing? Now there’s the rub, the hubris. Can anyone but God do such a thing? I suspect not. Humans have a nasty habit for grasping outside their reach and suffering the consequences. Viz: Quantum mechanics and destroyers of worlds. Turns out, the more we try to overcome nature, transcend it, the more alienated we actually become (See C. S. Lewis 1943 and R. Reno 2019).

But, on the face of it the idea is preposterous: You simply cannot get a dry, silicon-based algorithm-cruncher to embody HUMAN consciousness. Human consciousness springs from a wet, carbon-based being in a body in a in a world . Say what you will about where spirit/soul fits into this, we all must acknowledge that the brain in the body is at least the final common pathway for human existence, and necessary for it. The problem is, the brain is simply NOT a computational device. It is not a piece of hardware running a program that operates on data and spits out a result. David Chalmers’ “Hard problem of consciousness” (Chalmers 2022) should be enough to disabuse anyone of the idea that human consciousness could be embedded in a computer, no matter how powerful. That said, it seems clear that we CAN create machines that have intelligence, self-awareness even, and possibly also their own consciousness, but it will never be HUMAN consciousness, let alone an INDIVIDUAL human’s consciousness. So, the forward march of the meat-Lego deconstructionism that gave us transgenderism and on-demand abortion (or even infanticide/euthanasia if you follow Pete Singer) will hit a brick wall here: There is no way to get a dry silicon-based device to function like a wet carbon-based being. Unless pigs will fly.

Now I suppose we could create carbon-based beings, human clones, accelerate their growth and use them as avatars for our individual consciousnesses as our old bodies wear out (or even as warehouses for body parts as we might need them. See the 2005 movie “The Island” with Ewan McGreggor). Would it be possible then to implant an existing, external individual consciousness in such a biological avatar? Again, I think not. Given how the nervous system develops against the backdrop of individual lived experiences, there would be no way to engineer the structures needed to instantiate a consciousness fundamentally alien to that structure. Even if I were to clone myself tomorrow, that “person” would not be me since it would not have lived the life that I have lived and that has made me me. But what if we had some kind of StarTrek-like transporter/reduplicator that could replicate the biological form down to the last quantum gravitational fluctuation (after all, Kirk was once reduplicated in a parallel but opposite universe to great affliction of all!)? Well, I suppose. That would be an incredible feat of creative, all-powerful genius. It would, of course, also require an incredible, omniscient degree of understanding in order for the project to work at all. So, we’d need an all-powerful, all-knowing creative genius to pull this off. I don’t think we have one of those. No, wait, we DO have one of those:

God .

Previous
Previous

Mattering

Next
Next

New Year