Transhuman-2

So, we’ve talked about the upsurge in chatter about transhumanism. The issue brings up the question of how we define what it is to be human, or, more specifically, a “person”. The question itself seems a bit preposterous to me. You’d think it obvious. But here we are, and no wonder. We’ve lived an increasingly secularized world since the enlightenment (Taylor 2007) where positivism has expunged the ghost from the machine, then postmodernism made the machine irrelevant. We are all disembodied selves, but there is no self, really. So, we can abort unborn children on an industrial scale because, though we must concede they are HUMAN, we can just decide that they are not PERSONS, and so they can be done away with. The nazis did the same, just for Jews, Gypsies, homosexuals, the mentally challenged and a bunch of others. We can treat our bodies as so much meat-Lego (Harrington 2023) and surgically and/or chemically alter at will (though once you’ve cut off a body part it’s hard to put it back on). We can take DNA from skin cells of two individuals and put it into a de-DNA’d egg cell from some donor and grow a human in the lab. And finally (?), we’re going to figure out how to build a machine that can be and/or house a self, whatever that really is, or at the very least, grow clones of ourselves as repositories for the body parts that have a nasty habit of wearing out. Needless to say, the clones have no choice in the matter, regardless of what they might feel, whoever “they” might actually be… It’s quite the pickle.

But how did we get here. We didn’t do that overnight, and maybe the seed of it all was germinating in our dualist perspective since the beginning of time. We’ve been enthralled with substance dualism since antiquity. Plato had his forms that had (imperfect) copies here on earth. Biblical Scripture is full of passages that seem to argue for a mortal body and an immortal soul. The Gnostics had their esoteric knowledge and evil bodies. Descartes had his cogito that proved at least that there was something we not what that thinks and is separate from the body. Dualism is certainly convenient as we do have bodies that change while our “selves” seem to be the same over time, or more constant at least, though this too might be an illusion.

While we’ve dabbled in idealism (Kant, Hegel), we can’t seem to shake this idea that there is certainly some hard “stuff” “out there” that’s different than the “me” that’s “in here”, wherever “here” might be. Maybe the dualist enterprise is really the problem. Maybe it’s the wrong way to think about it, or at least a wrong way. We’re told that one wrong way is to think of soul as a separate “thing”, when it is really either an epiphenomenon or an illusion. All mind/soul states reduce to brain states. But maybe the wrongness is the other way around, maybe the material “stuff” we think we’re made of is really not that concrete after all? If we follow the quantum rabbit trail (Rovelli 2014 & 2017) we find out that “body”, or matter more fundamentally, is really “just” the interaction of quantum gravity and electromagnetism, with a dose of general relativity and quantum mechanics thrown in. Not really very “concrete” at all, and maybe not that different from “soul”. Now, “soul” has no placeholder in the equations that the theoretical physicists crank out, so it’s easily dismissed but this may be because the equations are incomplete, or we’re looking in the wrong place. Science, after all, is subtractive, which means you have an experimental condition from which you subtract the control condition to be left with the “solution”. If an element is in both the experimental and control conditions, then it is simply subtracted out and you won’t see it. If God is “all in all”, well, goes without saying that such an approach can easily miss that “factor”.

Another assumption that we make is that the material/physical properties of a system will exhaustively determine the system’s statistical properties. Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle is often misunderstood: He did NOT mean simply that you can’t know the velocity and mass of a particle at the same time but only one at a time. He discovered that uncertainty was a fundamental property of matter. Wave equations can allude to this uncertainty but not nail it down. Hmm. So, if matter isn’t really all that solid, maybe there is a different link between that which we consider mind/soul and that which we consider body. Maybe we need a completely different system to describe it? One curious thing is that any talk about mind/body must necessarily involve language and language has an unavoidable (and universal, Pinker 1994) tendency to force descriptions into a subject-verb-object formalism. There is an embedded “dualism” in the very structure of language that is likely spilling into our “understanding” of human being, mind/soul/body. Not sure I know how to get around that.

Finally, from a Biblical perspective, God, who can not only create everything Ex-Nihilo but also transform that which is corrupted into that which is perfect, can no doubt reassemble each individual human from a dead body into an imperishable one that is still recognizable as that individual person from some kind of “blueprint” of that person known only to God. I think there is too much sunk cost in the substance dualism Christianity has been saddled with. The Church is loath to jettison the concept and would rather sweep its problems under the carpet and carry on, than get untethered in a monist way of conceptualizing who we are. But maybe the Church is going to have to do so as transhumanism marches inexorably on. There is a lot of sunk cost in transhumanism too, particularly the idea that our physical bodies are ultimately irrelevant. This is manifest in the abortion industry, sexual liberation, “equal rights” (at least in a de Beauvoir [1953] sense), title IX and so on. Abigail Favale (2022) touches on some of this as she describes how our reproductive nature is central to our identity and how the negation of this central feature degrades us as humans. Mary Harrington (2023) does the same, as does C. S. Lewis (1943). As we seek to “overcome” nature, we abolish ourselves.

Previous
Previous

Stormy Weather

Next
Next

Mattering